Welcome to Big Tony's Pizzeria, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Marcellus, MI. Located at 290 South Centre St, this vibrant establishment has swiftly become a favorite among locals and newcomers alike, offering a delectable mix of pizza and subs that capture the essence of comfort food.

As you step inside, you’re greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere supported by the friendly smiles of owners Big Tony and Stephanie. Their passion for food is palpable and reflects in every dish that emerges from the kitchen—especially the pizzas. Each pie is crafted with care, featuring homemade crusts that promise a delightful balance of crisp and chew, a critical element that sets Big Tony’s apart from the mainstream pizza chains.

Critics and patrons rave about their specialty pizzas. Take Blue Buffalo Chicken, for example; it’s a story of flavor meeting texture. One visitor, Steve Hegedus II, was pleasantly surprised by the explosion of flavors in every bite, lauding the ranch sauce’s perfect balance with robust blue cheese and zesty buffalo sauce. The depth of flavor is an experience worthy of the wait, confirming that patience is indeed a virtue when it comes to ordering your favorite slice.

If you're in the mood for something different, don't miss the Southwest Chicken sub, which has garnered a strong fanbase, including Chelsey Elizabeth, who can’t get enough of it. And let’s not forget the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, which promises to be as indulgent as it is satisfying. Each dish is designed not just to fill you up but to enchant your palate with layers of flavor.

The locals praise Brett Martynowicz for describing their sauce as “the best on earth”—a bold claim backed by countless glowing reviews. Here, it’s all about flavor without excess grease, resulting in a pizza that you can savor guilt-free. This ethos extends to all offerings, ensuring consistent quality across the board.

For those who value a strong community feel, Big Tony’s is as much about the food as it is about the welcoming ambiance and impeccable service. Customers like Estela Salazar have remarked on the stellar service that enhances the dining experience, making every visit a delight.

Whether you're dining in or taking out, expect a clean environment and a pleasant experience, as highlighted by Pete Kean. And if you’re feeling extra hungry, indulge in their massive calzone—a signature dish that you’ll have trouble finishing by yourself!

For anyone craving a quality pizza experience that transcends the ordinary, Big Tony's Pizzeria is not to be missed. The combination of charming service, tantalizing offerings, and a menu that caters to every taste makes it a must-visit eatery in the Marcellus area. Don’t forget to call ahead at +1 269-646-2200 for a taste that’s truly unforgettable!